There's a long moment of Alfred just sort of standing there, working his jaw, trying to figure out how best to say what he needs to say in this situation - but this man seems rather like he's going to be disappointed if he does not become a vampire. And Alfred really can't relate to that.

Not...at...all.

Ahem.

"Well, I - I am...sorry, it's just - you do not get to...choose? I don't think? I was bitten before my arrival, and I was actively turning, but then when I got here, I was...human again. And then a month later...."

He gestures to his horns, his tail, the thick black claws he has filed down.